This site is funded by affiliate commissions. Links to shops may earn us a fee when you buy, at no extra cost to you. How that affects what we say.

How to choose a sex toy

Five questions that cut a wall of products down to two or three, with the trade-offs explained in plain language.

Updated 2026-11-16

Most buying regret comes from skipping the boring questions. Work through these five before you look at a single product page and the shortlist mostly writes itself.

1. Where do you want the sensation?

Toys split into a few families, and they feel very different.

  • External vibrators and wands rest on the outside of the body. Bullets and small massagers are gentle and quiet; wands are broad and strong.
  • Air-pulse (suction-style) stimulators use pulses of air near the clitoris instead of direct buzzing. Many people who find vibration numbing or too intense prefer them. There is no insertion.
  • Internal vibrators are shaped to be inserted and often curve to reach the G-spot.
  • Dual-action and wearable toys combine internal and external stimulation, and some can be worn during partnered sex.
  • Prostate massagers have a flared base and a curve designed for anal use.
  • Masturbators are sleeves or cups designed for penis stimulation.

2. Solo, partnered, or both?

A shape that works alone can be awkward with a partner in the way. If you want something for both, look at wearables and remote-controlled toys, which leave hands free.

3. How loud and how discreet?

Noise claims are rarely precise, so treat them with care. As a rule of thumb, small bullets and air-pulse toys tend to be quieter than large wands. If you share a wall, test a toy under a pillow or blanket, and check the maker's return policy before you open it.

4. What is it made of?

This is the one question where cheaper really can cost you. Read our materials guide: look for platinum-cured silicone, glass, stainless steel or sealed hard plastic, and avoid anything described as jelly, rubber or with a strong chemical smell.

5. How will it be powered and controlled?

  • Rechargeable is the norm now. Check whether it charges by USB cable or a proprietary magnetic one, because a lost proprietary cable can end a toy's life.
  • Waterproof matters for easy cleaning and for the bath. Look for an explicit rating and read what it covers; "splashproof" is not the same as submersible.
  • App control is useful for long-distance play but adds an account and permissions. See how app-controlled toys work before you pair anything.

Not sure where to start? Our beginner picks favour forgiving, quiet, easy-to-clean designs from makers with clear support.

Common questions

Should I buy the cheapest option first?

Not if it costs you on materials. A low price is fine for a basic design, but check the material and whether the maker publishes it. Porous, unlabeled materials are the thing to avoid, not low prices as such.

Is a more powerful toy better?

No. Power is not quality. Many people prefer a range of gentle settings, and a toy that is too strong is just as unsatisfying as one that is too weak. Look for a wide spread of intensity levels.

Related